Rate The Artwork Above You

[Ombre]

Ok, this is the deal, you post any kind of graphical art, and get it rated, it can be any kind of art you made, so dont be afraid to get out those drawings of Master Chief.
*I have permission from Echelon to make this thread here.*


Rules:
Only rate the art Above you.
Dont post scetches since its not really your work.
Only post artwork You have made.
Dont post without rating the art above you.
Try to give constructive Critism when rating.
Upload your images at: http://imageshack.us
If it is a large image please use the thumbnail code provided by Imageshack.
If you want to you may rate the artwork posted and the users signature.
Dont rate a artwork/signature you have already rated unless you have more critism.
If the person above you dosne't have a sig, you have already rated their sig, or they dont want it rated then rate the person above them.

*These rules are subject to change without warning. All the regular site rules apply.*


Let me start off by posting a Terragen

[GametagAeonFlux]

This belongs in Pictures mb?

[Ombre]

This belongs in Pictures mb?

I dont think so, since it has to do with sigs and avatars, and Ech was fine having it here i think.
8/10 nice and simple mini banner,

[GametagAeonFlux]

1) I didn't post any art.
2) I didn't make the sig, I use it to advertise.
3) On your render...it looks like a dry rocky mountainous place, why are there random puddles of water? The image is even NAMED Desert.
4) I like the foreground of the image, it's neat, but deserts dont have extremely high mountains.
5) Why is the mountain thin as a needle?

I could post more...but I'll let you answer+fix these 3 first.

[Ketchup_Bomb]

The image is even NAMED Desert.

Not all deserts are made out of sand and cacti.
In fact, some of the dryest places on earth are surrounded by water.

[RaVNzCRoFT]

I like that signature, Ketchup, except I don't really like the text or the render blending. I think you overblended the left side of it a little.



Please rate this signature. Ah, a revisit to one of my first grunge pieces.

[Ombre]

7/10 would be a 8/10 but the text dosent fit

[GametagAeonFlux]

LIEK ZOMG BEWBZ I RAIT IT 1010101010/10 LALWALWAL!!!

But seriously, 8/10, I like the brushing...

[Ombre]

LIEK ZOMG BEWBZ I RAIT IT 1010101010/10 LALWALWAL!!!

But seriously, 8/10, I like the brushing...

Gahhh next time post a sig or somthing? i think im like the only one actully posting stuff >.<
ugh had to make somthing so just made a quickie sig

[Waffle]

6/10...its OK color isnt good

rate my sig.

[Ombre]

8/10 looks pretty cool but render looks blury
rate my sig

[BFIGHTER]

Everything blends well besides the one brush on the left bottom corner..
seems outkast or sumthing but still pretty nice 7/10 or 8/10 im unsure
Rate my ugly sig.

[aaa]

9/10 love the bg

animation


rate
x/10

[Ombre]

6/10 pretty cool i guess but its really simple
Rate:

[aaa]

8/10 love the color

[RaVNzCRoFT]

I refuse to rate that sig until it abides by the new signature rules.


Bah, rate my current I guess.

[aaa]

7/10
but anyway its less than 75kb

[Ombre]

7/10
but anyway its less than 75kb

If you speak of you're current sig, then you are gravely mistaken, for it is around 90kb, anyways 6/10 pretty good, but the render needs to be bigger, text needs work, and i dont see a border.
Rate my sig.

[aaa]

new animation

[Ombre]

7/10 better then the last one but the hog should go slower and was that grunts? i couldent really tell it went to fast
Edit: oh and when hes driving the hog black lines appear and reappear to the right (if yo fixed those things it would be a 8.5/10)